Carroll House Restaurant Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing Carroll House Restaurant, a cozy breakfast spot in Sister Bay, WI, specializing in comfort food with a New American twist. Known for its generous portions, top menu picks include Sirloin and Eggs, Stuffed French Toast, Reuben Sandwich, Roast Beef, and Chicken Cashew. Customers praise the warm, home-cooked feel of the dishes, with highlights such as cherry stuffed waffles and chorizo hash. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make guests feel right at home, creating a charming dining experience. With options for vegetarian diners, outdoor seating, and catering services available, Carroll House Restaurant ticks all the boxes for a memorable breakfast or brunch outing. Don't miss out on this hidden gem that captures the essence of comfort dining.