Welcome to Carroll House Restaurant
Nestled in Sister Bay, WI, Carroll House Restaurant embodies the essence of comfort food with their hearty New American cuisine. From delectable Sirloin and Eggs to mouthwatering Stuffed French Toast, each dish is crafted with care and flavor. The welcoming staff create a warm, familial atmosphere, making every guest feel at home. With a focus on quality ingredients and generous portions, this cozy breakfast spot is a true gem for those seeking a delicious and satisfying meal. Whether enjoying a leisurely brunch or a quick bite, Carroll House Restaurant promises a memorable dining experience for all.
-
2445 S Bay Shore Dr Sister Bay, WI 54234 Hotline: (920) 854-7997
Welcome to Carroll House Restaurant, a cozy breakfast spot in Sister Bay, WI that exudes the warmth of a home-cooked meal. This hidden gem offers a variety of comfort food options in a casual and inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast, a delicious brunch, or a satisfying lunch, Carroll House Restaurant has something for everyone.
With a menu that includes popular items like Sirloin and Eggs, Stuffed French Toast, Reuben Sandwich, Roast Beef, and Chicken Cashew, there's no shortage of tasty dishes to choose from. The restaurant also caters to vegetarians with many options available.
Customer reviews rave about the friendly staff that make you feel like family, the generous portion sizes, and the homey ambiance that makes you want to linger over a cup of coffee. Whether you're a local looking for a familiar spot or a visitor in search of a comforting meal, Carroll House Restaurant is sure to leave you feeling satisfied and content.
Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience this breakfast gem that has been praised for its great service, delicious food, and fair prices. Make sure to try their cherry waffles, chorizo hash, or potato pancakes for a truly delicious meal that will make you feel right at home.
This cozy breakfast spot feels like a warm hug in food form. The home-cooked vibe is evident in every bite, generously sized pancakes were great and bacon cooked to perfection. The staff are welcoming and make you feel like family, adding to the overall charm. It's the kind of place where you can linger over a cup of coffee and feel right at home. A true breakfast gem!
Great coffee. Wonderful service. Waffle and bacon very good. I would vote this place as the 'most like home ' place on the peninsula! Cozy. Will go back again for sure!
Had the fish boil and we enjoyed learning about the history. Friendly staff and the food was great. We got the single and that was more than enough. The fresh homemade cherry pie at the end was awesome!
When you're told you've got a wait of 1hr 40min at Al Johnson's (and you know that means probably more like just an hour), we figured to drive up to Carroll House since we hadn't eaten and we figured to see how busy it really was since they weren't picking up the phone. Got there and seeing a few empty spots in the lot with folks leaving was a good sign. They were clearing a table as we got in. We got the chorizo hash ($12.75) and a full order of the cherry stuffed waffles ($11.75 - half order option also available for $7.75, and this can be done with French toast instead). Tables are turned over quickly and there is counter seating too. Check the current menu at their Facebook page. You can see they've been trying out new things, particularly it seems Mexican inspired options. Closes in December for the winter and reopens in April. FB page will help you on exact dates.
Just wanted to give a shout-out to this little family restaurant. It is definitely worth a visit for delicious homemade food. I ordered the potato pancakes for lunch and they were so good! Next time we'll go earlier for breakfast.
Nice restaurant as you're entering Sister Bay, not quite downtown which is great for breakfast on busy days. Quick service, friendly, good food.
We had a great breakfast here this morning. Cherry waffles, eggs. Everything was delicious. We come every year and this was my dad's favorite place for waffles.
Food, service and price were all excellent! A cozy morning breakfast! Oh and the coffee was very good too... it's small so expect to wait!